The quest for credibility

Media stories about North Korea often highlight the supposed eccentricity of its leader, the regime’s oppressive nature and the threat of nuclear war. Some mix error with exaggeration, making it difficult for readers to sift fact from fiction. Yet, as Duncan Bartlett discovered, experts strive for accuracy as they tell North Korea’s story

How should people respond when they see pictures of North Korea’s leader Kim Jong-un riding a white horse, or giving a piggyback to an elderly soldier?

Such photographs, distributed by North Korea’s propaganda ministry in 2017 and 2019, were used by the world’s media in a variety of contexts. Yet their deeper meaning was lost on those who don’t know the situation well, according to the BBC’s Korea Editor, Su Min Hwang.

‘It’s crucial to put the pictures in context and to offer as much insight as we can on what they mean for the North Koreans,’ Ms Hwang told a recent conference at Oxford University.

For example, both the white horse and piggyback images were analysed by BBC online, in stories that were widely read and shared.

Contrasting tones

‘The international media’s reports about North Korea carry different tones,’ said Ms Hwang. ‘Sometimes, there’s a comic tone about this weird country. At other times, there’s a very dark tone, with a soundtrack of solemn music. But I believe we have a responsibility to present a 360 degree picture.’

She explained that one of the challenges for the BBC – which does not assign its own reporters in North Korea – is verifying news that appears on international websites. ‘We see a lot of studies and analysis but we always need to ask what the sources are.’

Another panellist, Aidan Foster-Carter, Senior Honorary Fellow in Sociology and the Koreas at Leeds University in the UK, told the conference that North Korea watchers often end up looking repeatedly at the same set of data and ‘pass it around like a slice of cold, stale pizza’.

Noting that the North Koreans often ‘play’ the media, Dr Foster-Carter maintained, ‘They know we are watching and they send out false information.’

Defectors’ perspectives

Among the issues the conference discussed were those that arise from doing interviews with North Korean defectors, who ‘tell us that they will climb high mountains or walk many miles into the remote countryside to try to gain access to foreign television, radio or internet sources,’ said Su Min Hwang.‘Yet they also say that if you are caught watching a foreign film or listening to foreign music, the punishment can more severe than the punishment for murder.’

She therefore urged caution in accepting defectors’ comments at face value, warning that ‘some people are paid to speak to the media, so there’s a risk of exaggeration. We are aware of the danger of being fed misinformation through defectors’.

The quest for accuracy

Su Min Hwang, BBC Korea Editor
Su Min Hwang, BBC Korea Editor

Ms Hwang said the BBC takes great care over its sources of information and informs its audience when there is ambiguity. ‘We value accuracy more than speed at the BBC. We’d rather wait until things become clear. For example, when Kim’s train went to China, there were a lot of rumours flying around. But we waited until we had official verification that it was actually him before we reported the trip,’ she said.

The media struggle to obtain accurate information about weapons tests and the development of nuclear facilities. Reporters often turn to experts to analyse developments but the conference heard that this can create further challenges.

It is similarly difficult for the press to accurately assess the North Korean economy. The central bank of South Korea offers estimates which are widely read, although its data is partly based on speculation.

Economic pressure

It is evident that North Korea’s economy is harmed by multilateral sanctions, which are strongly supported by America and its allies. In recent years those sanctions have become tighter, although Isabel Hilton, CEO and Editor of China Dialogue, told the conference: ‘China is busy busting the sanctions in order to keep the system going, in the hope that this will stave off any difficult or embarrassing collapse of the regime.’

Several people at the meeting noted that Kim Jong-un has made the economic revival of North Korea a priority, although it is hard to assess the situation because of a lack of reliable economic data.

Edward Howell, a lecturer in politics at New College, Oxford said: ‘For the North Koreans, pretty pictures of Kim cutting the ribbons at factories or meeting with workers are no longer enough. They are seeking evidence of economic development.’

Expensive weapons

Many North Koreans, said Dr Howell,‘are asking how the country can justify the nuclear weapons programme. I have spoken to defectors who have told me that as soon as they found out how much it cost, they wondered why the money was not being spent on them, or on the country’s more impoverished regions.’

Another participant, who has close links to the South Korean government, said that the impact of the sanctions is diluted by the support North Korea receives from both China and Russia.He noted that negotiations aimed at dismantling North Korea’s nuclear and missile programmes are currently stalled, and this creates frustration for South Korea.

‘We need to rebuild trust,’ said the South Korean government spokesperson.‘In a situation where one partner is much stronger than the other, it is up to the stronger partner to take the first steps. So in our view, the responsibility lies with the United States, although it seems very difficult for President Trump to take those measures.’

He continued: ‘Kim offers many promises to his people of a better life and that was the strong message he sent before his last meeting with President Trump in Hanoi. Yet he came back from that meeting with nothing. In my personal opinion, he has lost face.’

Professor Rana Mitter (l) joins other panellists at the Oxford China Centre
Professor Rana Mitter (l) joins other panellists at the Oxford China Centre

Denuclearisation

On the issue of denuclearisation, the Director of the Oxford China Centre, Professor Rana Mitter, was concerned that ‘China’s red lines include no regime change and no re-unification of the two Koreas, which leaves a large US troop presence on the border with China’.

Professor Mitter said that ‘unfortunately’ he does not see a path towards complete denuclearisation because it would be extremely difficult ‘to prise all the weapons out of the hands’ of the North. One solution, he believed, could be a deal which removes the intercontinental weapons but allows the North to retain some short-range missiles.

The panel concurred, though, that this would present a serious problem for both South Korea and Japan, which would resist a formal deal in which they remain under threat of a nuclear attack by a neighbouring nation.


The conference at the Oxford China Centre was moderated by Bill Emmott, chair of the International Institute for Strategic Studies,and organised by Asian Agenda

Duncan Bartlett is the Editor of Asian Affairs and author of the weekly blog Japan Story. He formerly worked in Tokyo for the BBC

 Related Post